The Scotland vs USA rugby 2025 Autumn Nations Series opener on November 1st produced a stunning result as Scotland demolished the United States at Murrayfield, with the Scotland 85-0 USA highlights cementing the largest victory margin in the venue’s century-long history and Scotland’s third-biggest win ever.
Rugby pundits’ reactions to the Scotland match were overwhelmingly positive despite the one-sided nature. Former Sevens star Colin Gregor praised Scotland’s clinical execution, stating they “capitalized on nearly all the line breaks they created” while maintaining cohesion throughout. Chief sportswriter Tom English acknowledged the scoreline “accurately reflects the match,” noting several players made compelling cases for selection against New Zealand.
The Gregor Townsend Scotland performance assessment emphasized squad cohesiveness despite fielding a reshuffled lineup. The head coach highlighted that “straight away, the players were very cohesive which is hard to achieve in a week’s training, with a brand-new team,” praising the effort and physicality displayed. Townsend admitted he “can’t wait” for the All-Blacks challenge, recognizing the massive step-up in competition.
Jamie Dobie earned player-of-the-match honors with a hat-trick after starting at scrumhalf and shifting to the wing, with former Scotland prop Peter Wright describing his performance as “exceptional”. Darcy Graham also claimed a hat-trick, moving level with Duhan van der Merwe on 34 Test tries for Scotland. The Scotland rugby record win over Murrayfield featured 13 total tries, with the score reaching 45-0 by halftime. Edinburgh debutant Liam McConnell impressed with explosive runs and a lineout steal, prompting Townsend to acknowledge the 21-year-old’s promising future despite limited professional experience. USA coach Scott Lawrence admitted his side were “shell-shocked” by Scotland’s intensity in one of their worst defeats.
